Side by side · verified from each firm's own pages

City Traders Imperium vs Goat Funded Trader

Rules placed next to each other, with the calculation basis written out — because two firms quoting the same percentage can be measuring completely different things.

What differs most.

They calculate the daily loss limit from different reference points, so the percentages are not directly comparable.

Account closed
Trading day over, account survives
Room to lose on day one
Profit still needed to pass phase one

Drawn to scale from each plan's own published numbers, on the plan compared in the table below. Day one is the only day on which every daily-loss basis agrees, which is what makes the two bars honestly comparable at all. Both maximum-loss floors sit at the same place on day one, $90,000. The two daily-loss floors are measured from different reference points, so they only line up on day one. From day two they move apart.

	City Traders Imperium Comoros Union	Goat Funded Trader Hong Kong
Disclosure score	Partially documented	Fully documented
Challenge from	$39 list, USD	Not yet verified
Plan compared	2-Step Challenge	2-Step Standard
Model	2-Step	2-Step
Profit target	10% → 5%	10% → 5%
Daily loss limit	5% of the balance recorded at day start, on balance, closed trades only	5% of the higher of the previous day’s closing balance or closing equity, on balance or equity. Resets 5:00 PM EST
Maximum loss limit	10% Static floor, from initial balance	10% Static floor, from initial balance
Consistency	No consistency rule	No consistency rule
Stop loss	Not required	Not required
Best profit split	80% Funded (start)	100% With 100% split add-on
Weekend holding	Allowed	Not yet verified
News trading	Allowed	Restricted window
Inactivity breach	Not yet verified	30 days
Retroactive rule changes	0	0
Operator jurisdiction	Comoros Union (Anjouan)	Hong Kong
Regulator disclosed	Not yet verified	Not yet verified
Restricted countries	North Korea, Iran, Syria, Cuba, Russia, and any individual under international sanctions (site footer, 5 named).	Afghanistan, Belarus, Central African Republic, Chile, Cuba, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Hong Kong, Iran, Israel, Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant and Al-Qaida, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Mali, Myanmar, North Korea, Russia, Senegal, Singapore, Somalia, South Korea, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Togo, Venezuela, Yemen, Zimbabwe (help centre, dated 27 July 2026). Hong Kong appears on this list while the contracting company is registered in Hong Kong. MetaTrader 5 is stated as not intended for US citizens or residents.

Only the first recorded plan of each firm is shown here. Full plan detail, sources and everything we could not verify are on each firm's page. Last verified 7 September 2026.

Not yet verified is not No. Where a cell reads "Not yet verified", we could not confirm the rule from the firm's own terms or help centre. It is not a claim that the rule does not exist.